I rarely watch anything made outside of Japan nowadays
That's not because of weeaboo snobbery or anything like that; it's just that there's little else that I have any interest in watching. There seems to very very little new programming in the West that's good (of course, I haven't been making an effort to catch up, and I don't have a TV for half of the year).
However, I'm in the same boat as the doc when it comes to favourite genre; I haven't watched any non-comedy Western TV programmes for many years, and I don't watch much "serious" anime either (the exceptions are Fate/Stay Night, which I only decided to watch because I liked the VN, Spice and Wolf, which I only watch because I'm furry for Horo and Rozen Maiden, which I only decided to watch because of the desu). I have a
myanimelist account, which documents my woefully low level of anime consumption
As for Western programming, I like Britcoms from the 90s and 00s, most things with Stephen Fry or Rowan Atkinson in them and/or that are written by Richard Curtis and Ben Elton and animation aimed at older audiences; The Simpsons (the older episodes, of course), Futurama, Family Guy, King of the Hill and the absolutely brilliant Monkey Dust.