The wonderful K.O.R. (Whimiscal Orange Road)
I actually crushed on Madoka when I was younger. I used to also have a T-shirt with her on it.
What's funny was I was so emotionally tied up with the movie (Where Hyosuke *FINALY* sleeps with Madoka at the end) I was almost driven to tears. A few years later, I was explaining the show's premise to my then-girlfriend. I talked about how the family all has magic powers and how Kyosuke was in love with a girl and was powerless to do anything about it dispite all the abilities he had.
I conviced her to watch the movie, only to realize that, in the end, no one even used thier powers al all! Not only this, it wasn't even mentioned in the WHOLE MOVIE.
My then-girlfriend thought it was the lamest cartoon in history because she was expecting magic powers and stuff.
Oh well.