1. 7h is an awful, convoluted, badly designed, gimmicky solution that tries to be an all size fits gauntlet. Even installing the cretinous thing is a chore. I hated it from the start, but hoped it would get better. When I realized it wouldn't, I decided to make my own solution.
But it works. Usually. It's gotten worse as MSFT changes stuff, but there's nothing the original authors could have done about that. You've mentioned your system several times, but as far as I know, nobody outside your core Reunion team has seen it, causing everyone else (like that troll a couple months back) to go into "show it or stuff it" mode. I'm a little more patient than that, but making a YouTube demonstration to see if it's a direction we'd all like to go in would be pretty cool, and possibly help some of the graphics folks prep their own mods for easy inclusion in your system.
2. You've caught me on a very bad day.
Nothing we can do about that besides buy you a pint. Or five...
My aim is to kill 7h off.
I'm not going to attempt to dissuade you from this goal, but since I know you're generally against releasing your source, I will remind you that this decision means you're going to be the one responsible for dealing with ALL the bug reports, ALL the bug fixing, ALL the support, ALL the whining, and ALL the unsolicited "Make this absolutely asinine change because I think it's cool RIGHT FSCKIN MEOW!!!!" demands.
6. It's nothing to do with "taking control" It's the following:
b. It takes MY control of MY mod away from me. The same way it takes away control of any modder's mod.
c. People start to believe 7h IS the mod. That the work was done by 7h team.
I'm not sure how you come to the conclusion that it's taking control away from you. This is the internet... once it's out there, it's out there forever. There's crap I posted almost 30 years ago still floating around Usenet, and the wayback archive still has a snapshot or two from my undergrad webpage (even though the server itself has been offline for at least a decade). I do totally agree with the annoyance of people thinking 7H is the mod... seen it plenty myself, and want to smack them upside the head.
I wonder if the compromise was making Reunion the mod manager/integrator and 7 Heaven the mod library/downloader?
This would be an absolute maintenance and coordination nightmare.
I dont like installing mods that require their own installer, primarily the issues are I dont know whats been replaced/updated by the installer, and also that typically these mods are not modular in the sense they play well with other mods.
This is the number one weakness in the current Reunion system. But DLPB promises that he's giving us a new method, so I'm taking a "wait and see" stance... The beauty of 7H is its modularity and "hands-off" approach to the original files. Of course, that also makes it brittle and vulnerable to MSFT's latest whimsy (as we so often see)
The issue raised by DLPB losing control of MO on 7thheaven I assume could be resolved by a conversation with alyzza to get it removed from that catalog and then making his own iro which he maintains by himself, sega chief maintains his own iro for new threat. I have never heard of anyone who thinks 7thheaven is the actual mod.
Making a catalog is a long, boring, repetitive, and almost entirely thankless process, which is why updates are so rarely compiled. I personally think catalogs are best suited for static, "release and done" projects like graphics and sound overhauls. Mods which are constantly being updated or are otherwise flexible (Reunion and New Threat being the two most obvious examples) are really better off kept in their respective release threads so people can always fetch the latest and greatest, while the authors can kill links to older versions as appropriate.