Author Topic: The Rules  (Read 17043 times)

obesebear

  • Administrator
  • No life
  • *
  • Posts: 3213
  • Karma: 109
    • View Profile
The Rules
« on: 2010-07-09 16:25:42 »
RULES
This is the rules page. I welcome all of our older members and new members to read over these and familiarize yourself with them. All users (even brand new ones) are expected to know and follow these rules. Ignorance of the rules is not an excuse. You registered for an account on these forums and thus you should know these.


We Do Not Condone Software Piracy
Asking where to get illegal software or cracks will not be tolerated. Asking for support for the Ultima Edition or any other pirated version of the game will not be tolerated. Any discussion regarding pirated software is an immediate warning. Assisting people that use pirated software is also forbidden.


We Do Not Allow Ripped Content
Content ripped from other games, including models, backgrounds, textures, etc., is not to be distributed or requested. This content is just as copyrighted as the games it's ripped from. Please only distribute things either you created yourself, or you have permission to distribute.


Asking for Help
We are here to help, but like to see people who try to help themselves.
  • Try to find an answer by searching the Qhimm forums, there's also our Wiki Page.
  • Try to find an answer by searching the Web
  • Try to find an answer by experimentation!
  • If you still cannot find a solution, make sure your post includes information about what you've tried.
  • Be patient. We can't all be online all the time, and nagging will make us want to help you less, and may lead to warnings.

Posting Etiquette
  • Double posting is generally not allowed. If your last post was less than 24-48 hours ago, edit your post.
  • Posting in threads more than a month old IS allowed. However, if your post contains no relevant information it will likely be deleted and you will be warned. If a link is broken, inform the author by using a Private Message.
  • CAPS LOCK MAKES IT LOOK LIKE YOU'RE BEING AGGRESSIVE!! WE DON'T LIKE AGGRESSIVE PEOPLE!! SO DON'T USE IT!
  • Smilies and shorthand (like lol) have a place in a message board, but too many can be annoying. If the amount of smileys you post is more than 1/5 of your word count, you may consider cutting some of them.
  • Everyone interprets things differently than others depending on their culture, life experiences, and many other factors. If somebody posts a message that could be considered insulting or offensive to you, don't immediately flame them.
  • Don't insult anyone. Report to a moderator if someone has insulted and/or threatened you. Responding in kind could get you warned as well.
  • Be constructive with your criticism, if you like someones work then take the time to explain why rather than cluttering a thread with random words like "Nice" or "Cool". Similarly, if you don't like the work then be polite enough to offer advice on how it could be improved.
  • Learn to use grammar and punctuation. Use of a spell checker is a good idea as well. "lol y evrone noes wat im sayin :?: :?: lol" is not an acceptable way of writing. Remember a well worded post shows respect to the people that are reading it.
  • Try not to quote images. There is no need for it. If you wish to quote a post that contains an image just remove the link from the quote.
  • Image macro's will be confined to Completely Unrelated. There is no reason for them to be elsewhere as they add nothing to the discussion. This is not /b/.

Posting to Specific Boards
General guidelines on what should be posted where. These will be enforced. Obviously there will be some overlap between boards and there may be some confusion on which area a topic should reside in. Any gray area on where a topic should go will be decided by a moderator.

General Discussion
This is the "catch all" forum. Feel free to post anything pertaining to one of the Final Fantasies. If you don't think your thread really fits in any of the other forums, putting it here is just fine.

Audio/Graphical/Gameplay/Other Mods
These forums are for incomplete mods. Try to use common sense when creating threads; your custom Cloud model may be beautiful, but it doesn't belong in Audio mods.
     Releases
     These subforums are for released mods. As a general rule these should be pretty much complete.

Aali's Custom FF7/FF8 Driver
This forum is only for Aali's driver. If you're playing FF7 for the PC, chances are you either ARE using this, or should be. Only Aali can post in the release thread. All questions/comments related to hid driver go in the other one.

Tools
This forum is what makes EVERYTHING possible. Only threads containing programs that edit the game go here. No need for an example on this one. Programs only.

Troubleshooting
For ANY problems or questions about the game. However, if your problem concerns a specific program or mod, it will make it a lot easier to help if you post in the thread where you downloaded it.

Scripting and Reverse Engineering
This forum is about further advancement of editing the game. If there is something you would like to edit about the game (not concerning models), but can't find any info on how to do it, put your question here. If you've been exploring the game engine and found something new and useful, put it here.

Archive
Older threads. No posting here, just a reference for old times' sake.

Completely Unrelated
Anything goes. Things unrelated to Final Fantasy, image macros, double posting, reviving year old topics, and L337 $P34|<.  However, all the big rules still apply.

Q-Gears/FF7Voice/Team Avalanche
These forums are only for their respective projects. If you've got something to say or ask about one of them, it goes in here.


Use Meaningful, Specific Subject Headers
When posting a new thread, consider the subject header carefully. The subject is your opportunity to attract people to your thread, so it's in your own best interests to use it properly.

Stupid: HELP ME!!

Smart: Help required with getting model into FF7

Smarter: FF7 model importing issues - problem with assigning textures.


Don't Be a D*ck
Be courteous, polite and show respect to others. Use of the forums is a privilege, not a right. Being a d*ck may get you warned. It may get you moderated. You might get banned for being a d*ck. Even if you are right and someone else is wrong, keep things civil. Incendiary comments directed at individuals or groups of members are not allowed.

If you really can't get along with someone, you can put them on ignore. But don't mention the fact you're ignoring someone as a taunt or parting shot - just do it quietly. Telling someone you're ignoring them to insult them is prohibited.


We Hate Spam
We don't want to buy your WOW gold, mobile phones or shoes. We already know where the porn is on the internet, so we don't need links to that either.

Post any of this and you will be banned.

Actually, you're best off not advertising anything on this site that isn't helpful to creating for or learning about Final Fantasy. If you feel you need to advertise anything, there are literally thousands of other forums where you can do that.


We Are Not Your "Blog"
What we mean by this, is please don't create mindless threads that are extremely off-topic.

If you have a topic of reasonable discussion to post, then by all means, please post away and let the intelligent discussion begin. However, we do not want to see random posts of "I ate cookies today" or "My car is blue", etc. etc. Even within the Completely Unrelated forum, there is no place on Qhimm for such threads. They provide no topic for discussion and are generally useless and become filled with useless replies.

"More mods, less words" is a good mantra to go by when considering yourself a contributing member of the Qhimm community.

We generally hand out Warnings for such threads, so please think about what it is you'd like to post, and how it will benefit a community of video game artists and modders.


Avatars
Avatars are a privilege not a right. Keep to these rules regarding avatars or suffer the consequences.
  • Maximum picture size - 100x100 pixels
  • Maximum file size - 10kb

Multiple Accounts
There is absolutely no reason to have more than one account. If you wish to change your display name you can change it in your profile. If anyone is found with more than one account they risk both accounts being banned.


Reporting Posts
We ask users that see a violation of the rules to use the report post function. This will give all moderators notice that an infraction has occured. Posting in the thread itself is not advised. eg: Do not post in a thread that was inactive for years. Just because someone else necro'd a topic doesn't mean it is ok for others to post in it. Moderators can't be everywhere at once... These are your forums, if you see a problem, report it. Please note that reporting PMs is currently broken.

Only use the report button to report actual rule infractions. Do not use it to report mods or tools that don't work, missing download links, members being unable to solve your problems despite their best effort, or updates that take longer than you hoped. If you cannot cite the exact rule being broken, chances are pretty good you shouldn't be reporting the post. Abuse of the report button will lead to warnings and potential moderation.


Warnings
A warning system is in place to help enforce the rules. To help you understand how the system works I will outline it below. Keep in mind each day that passes the warning level will lower by 2% until you are back at 0, at which point the icon will be removed from your username. (but off course you will never be warned, right?)

Level 1 (1-20%) Watched - User is placed on a moderator watch list. This allows moderators to see how frequently a user is breaking the rules. A green icon will appear under your username. This type of warning is simply to record what rule a user has broken.

Level 2 (21-40%) Moderated - User is placed in a moderator approval mode. This means that any posts that the user makes will need to be approved before the post is actually posted. A user will be moderated if rules are being broken at a frequent rate. Users may still gain more warnings in regards to the content of the posts awaiting approval.

Level 3 (41%+) Muted - User is banned from posting entirely, but will still be able to read posts. This type of warning will be dealt if the rule breaking appears deliberate and defiant. The only time you will see this is when a permanent ban is being considered. If you reach this level it is a good idea to really reflect on what you've done and plead your case to the moderators/admins as soon as you can.


Private Messages
Users must have a minimum of five posts before they are able to send PMs. Do not post spam or meaningless threads to raise your post count, as such posts will be deleted, will not count toward the minimum, and may result in a warning. The same rules apply to PMs that apply to the public boards.



If you feel there is something that needs changing, post it here. Any personal complaints should be taken to a moderator or staff member (Obesebear, sl1982, halkun, Bosola, Covarr, EQ2Alyza, Vgr) via Private Message.
« Last Edit: 2016-01-11 16:35:04 by Covarr »

Kudistos Megistos

  • Banned
  • No life
  • *
  • Posts: 3936
  • Karma: 1
    • View Profile
Re: The Rules
« Reply #1 on: 2010-07-22 16:32:12 »
I think another discussion about the rules regarding what posts go where is needed, because it seems to me that the new rules are causing problems that never used to exist.

When I look at a lot of threads nowadays, I see a huge string of people with "watched" or "moderated" underneath their names. For people that have signed up and posted recently, those who aren't being moderated in some way seem to be in the minority. Some of these people deserve to be on the watch list; if people are repeatedly quadruple necroposting with questions about the Ultima edition, there's a good reason to moderate them.

However, a lot of the people being moderated seem to have committed very minor infractions, and some of them are moderated because they posted a thread in the wrong board. Why is this a problem with the rules rather than the poster? It's for four reasons. Th first is that the rules on what goes where do not make sense, and I touched upon this earlier. If a user is in any doubt at all about where their post is supposed to go (and for first time users, I don't think the rules are as clear as the people who wrote them think they are), then all they can do is apply common sense. Common sense dictates, for example, that a thread about modifying the game, whether or not the mod will lead to a release, should go in game tweaking. And yet this is not the case, and a user who posts a thread about tweaking the game in that forum may get moderated.

The second reason is that new users are getting conflicting information. The rules do not match up with the board descriptions or the board names. When a new user is getting different information from different sources, how is he to know what to do? Once again, the newcomer is likely to get confused and will put the thread where it seems more logical.

The fourth reason is that we are likely to make an even worse name for ourselves than we already have. I'm not sure how many people know this, but a lot of discussions about these forums on other parts of the internet have people saying things along the lines of "they're great modders and they know a lot about the game, but they're arseholes, especially to newbies". Surprisingly, not all of these people are saying this because they ran into me; some of these complains pre-date kudistos megistos. That reputation is likely to get even worse. New people will come here, read the rules and look at the board names and descriptions, be confused, put the thread where it seems most logical, and then get shouted at and moderated. They will then go away and tell everyone how awful we are. I'm aware that some people might respond to this by saying that you don't care what people say about us, but I do think it's important that we don't get ourselves a bad reputation and we don't scare away people who might become valuable members because they either heard bad things about us or because they got shouted at on their first day for something that they didn't know was wrong.

The fourth reason, and I think this is the most significant, is that "what goes where" wasn't a problem before. It is now.

Game tweaking may have been a catch all in the past, but at least it meant that there was very little arguing about where threads go. There really weren't many problems with the way things worked before when "what goes where" was fairly intuitive; problems have only recently begun to arise and I can't see what benefits we have that would justify the cost.

We'd be far better off by going back to the old rules on what goes where, or by completely revising the whole thing so that we have one board that is for programs, released mods and WIPs, one board for tech support, one for playing with the mechanics of the game and one board for general (non-modding) FF discussions. If we had something like this, I doubt there would be any problems at all with knowing what goes where.

sl1982

  • Administrator
  • No life
  • *
  • Posts: 3608
  • Karma: 32
  • GUI Master :P
    • View Profile
Re: The Rules
« Reply #2 on: 2010-07-22 17:08:47 »
I do agree with this for the most part. Having the rules and the forum descriptions different is very counter productive. This is the reason why I have not given anyone a warning for posting in the wrong area (and I have moved quite a few posts.) Anyways, until we can get qhimm to change the layout and description of the forums I think we should be lenient on posting in specific areas.

obesebear

  • Administrator
  • No life
  • *
  • Posts: 3213
  • Karma: 109
    • View Profile
Re: The Rules
« Reply #3 on: 2010-07-22 17:13:29 »
Attracting new people is great.  Having a reputation for being "arseholes" means that when people come here from those boards, they are more likely to conduct themselves in a respectful manner, which is even greater.  No "leet speak", decent grammar, and are more likely to pay serious attention to the rules we have in place.  Personally, I would be just fine and dandy if these forums consisted of only a select few people.  But new people will join, and keeping this forum semi-professional is of great importance to me.

"What goes where" was a problem before.  Perhaps you don't remember Game Tweaking being nearly the only forum being posted in?  I agree that the forums could use a serious revision.  Fact is, moderators have no control over it.  So we are stuck with how things are.  The reason forum content is heavily kept in check, especially Game Tweaking, is to make searching easier.  Game Tweaking is meant to be for programs and mods.  Not questions.  If a newcomer is confused if their post is in the appropriate place, it can go in General as long as it's FF related.   There is already a thread about proposing new forum structure, feel free to add your 2 cents in there.  If it's good we can all petition Qhimm to implement it.  Though so far even my suggestion to add a few subforums has been rejected.

About the warning system.  Being warned means nothing, the only consequence is that a subsequent warning is more likely lead to being moderated for a few days.  Even if you break a rule or two, as long as it appears you have a strong grasp of them, it's unlikely you'll ever be more than warned.

Kudistos Megistos

  • Banned
  • No life
  • *
  • Posts: 3936
  • Karma: 1
    • View Profile
Re: The Rules
« Reply #4 on: 2010-07-22 17:36:39 »
Attracting new people is great.  Having a reputation for being "arseholes" means that when people come here from those boards, they are more likely to conduct themselves in a respectful manner, which is even greater.

The empirical evidence suggests otherwise...

"What goes where" was a problem before.  Perhaps you don't remember Game Tweaking being nearly the only forum being posted in?

Why was that was a problem? Most of the posts went in game tweaking because most of the topics being posted were about tweaking the game. I don't recall there being any problems at all; at least everyone knew where everything went.

The reason forum content is heavily kept in check, especially Game Tweaking, is to make searching easier.

Searching is harder because the rules on what goes where have suddenly changed. Whereas previously one only had to search game tweaking if one wanted info on something to do with tweaking the game, one now needs to search game tweaking (to look for older posts) and general (to search for newer ones). For some reason, there's now a limit on searches as well, which means one has to search one forum, wait, and then search another. I've found that searching has been a lot more bothersome recently. I foresee a lot of people asking questions that have already been answered if they are unaware that the rules have changed recently and only search general; they'll miss threads on the topics they want to know about if those topics were posted in game tweaking months or years ago.

obesebear

  • Administrator
  • No life
  • *
  • Posts: 3213
  • Karma: 109
    • View Profile
Re: The Rules
« Reply #5 on: 2010-07-23 08:04:54 »
Just discovered this http://forums.qhimm.com/index.php?topic=4241.0 Jari's first post is basically exactly how I run things.

Kudistos Megistos

  • Banned
  • No life
  • *
  • Posts: 3936
  • Karma: 1
    • View Profile
Re: The Rules
« Reply #6 on: 2010-07-23 15:17:17 »
Just discovered this http://forums.qhimm.com/index.php?topic=4241.0 Jari's first post is basically exactly how I run things.

There's a context to that post; be wary of taking it at face value. When Jari was an admin, or at least when he was in his most recent stint as admin, he was quite sparing with his powers and only really used them for major offences and repeat offences. Besides the Mako incident, and to a certain extent, the ongoing Seifer saga, none of his decisions caused any controversy IIRC.

There were also, I assume, a different set of rules at the time; I doubt he was talking about banning people for not knowing what board a topic should go into. More likely, it's using mod powers for stuff that should be obvious like Ultima editions and ridiculous double and necroposts. I might be wrong, but since no-one in that thread made too much of an issue, I'm going to assume the rules that were talked about were pretty uncontroversial ones.

BTW, it doesn't deal at all with the specific rules that I'm criticising. I'm still waiting to hear why having a large proportion of the forum's posts going in one board was so bad that the current situation, in which general is a far worse catch-all board than game tweaking ever was and in which people are getting moderated because they don't know what board posts go in, is preferable.

EDIT:

I have made a post in the "My suggestion to make the site flow better" thread.
« Last Edit: 2010-07-23 16:01:15 by Kudistos Megistos »

obesebear

  • Administrator
  • No life
  • *
  • Posts: 3213
  • Karma: 109
    • View Profile
Re: The Rules
« Reply #7 on: 2010-07-23 16:06:05 »
I said Jari's post is how i run things.  Not that we're reliving those days and the exact same situations apply.

It's preferable because that is how I've chosen to do things.  And no one has been moderated for posting in the wrong section, only warned; hell some have just been deleted... no warnings at all.  Happy yet?

Kudistos Megistos

  • Banned
  • No life
  • *
  • Posts: 3936
  • Karma: 1
    • View Profile
Re: The Rules
« Reply #8 on: 2010-07-23 16:15:19 »
And no one has been moderated for posting in the wrong section, only warned

Really? I see people with "watched" under their name because they posted something in the wrong forum. I'd call that being moderated. I mean, only mods can do it, and it's an official warning rather than an unofficial one (which most people would see as preferable for minor infringements).

It's preferable because that is how I've chosen to do things.

At least you're being honest.

I suppose that if you'd decided that game tweaking was for discussions about Hermoor, programming feedback was for discussions about FF7Voice and Completely Unrelated was the place for tech support, that would be preferable as well. Obviously, it doesn't matter that the situation would make the forums less usable for everyone; once Judge Dredd makes his decision, it will not be changed.

sl1982

  • Administrator
  • No life
  • *
  • Posts: 3608
  • Karma: 32
  • GUI Master :P
    • View Profile
Re: The Rules
« Reply #9 on: 2010-07-23 17:28:40 »
I understand what you are saying. But bitching at us about it is going to solve nothing. Trust me, if i could have changed the layout of the forums i would have already. I will talk to qhimm when I am able to and see if he can at least change the wording of the sub-forums to make it less confusing for new people.

As for the warning, that is all that it is. Nothing changes for the user except for that little watched icon. Consider it a visual reminder to follow the rules.

As for banning, there is no real ban system. A moderated user will have to submit his post for moderator approval. And a muted user will not be able to post. For the moment there has only been 1 muted user, and I think everyone would agree that he needed to be.

Either way people will buttercup. People complained when there was no moderation, people will complain when there is.

Kudistos Megistos

  • Banned
  • No life
  • *
  • Posts: 3936
  • Karma: 1
    • View Profile
Re: The Rules
« Reply #10 on: 2010-07-23 18:07:20 »
Trust me, if i could have changed the layout of the forums i would have already.

What a shame. But you can change that post you made with the rules in it, can't you? Perhaps to something more along the lines of this. How convenient that the old rules on what goes where, which seem to have worked a lot better, have been thrown in the trashcan because they contradict the new ones! ;D

As for the warning, that is all that it is. Nothing changes for the user except for that little watched icon. Consider it a visual reminder to follow the rules.

Using mod powers, even if they don't stop a person from posting, is very significant. It implies that what has been done is so severe that an unofficial warning is not enough, and it also marks the person. Fortunately the mark isn't a very bad one since very few people nowadays don't have some kind of warning, but that also means it can't work very well as a visual reminder to follow the rules.

Either way people will b*tch. People complained when there was no moderation, people will complain when there is.

Either way people will break the rules, so I suppose there's no point in doing anything about it and we should get rid of all the moderators. See what I did there? ;D

And it isn't a case of people bitching when there is moderation and when there isn't; it's a case of people finding that the forums are harder to use when there is under moderation and when there is over-moderation. Don't exclude the middle.

sl1982

  • Administrator
  • No life
  • *
  • Posts: 3608
  • Karma: 32
  • GUI Master :P
    • View Profile
Re: The Rules
« Reply #11 on: 2010-07-23 18:10:04 »
You are forgetting one thing though. There only seems to be one person bitching about the moderation.

Kudistos Megistos

  • Banned
  • No life
  • *
  • Posts: 3936
  • Karma: 1
    • View Profile
Re: The Rules
« Reply #12 on: 2010-07-23 18:11:58 »
You are forgetting one thing though. There only seems to be one person bitching about the moderation.

Maybe the rest don't want to get banned?

That's another consequence of over-zealous moderation; people are afraid to disagree with the moderators because they don't want to be punished.

EDIT:

Oh, and I don't remember a single person complaining about how the old rules on what goes where used to work...
« Last Edit: 2010-07-23 18:22:00 by Kudistos Megistos »

sl1982

  • Administrator
  • No life
  • *
  • Posts: 3608
  • Karma: 32
  • GUI Master :P
    • View Profile
Re: The Rules
« Reply #13 on: 2010-07-23 18:22:14 »
So if i understand you correctly you have no problem with people getting warned for posting in the wrong area. You just dont like the new way things are layed out. Or do you have a problem with the warnings as well? Should I have let the guy who posted a problem getting the game running in the ff7voice forum away with it? Or is that ok with you since it is not so much of a grey area?

Kudistos Megistos

  • Banned
  • No life
  • *
  • Posts: 3936
  • Karma: 1
    • View Profile
Re: The Rules
« Reply #14 on: 2010-07-23 18:31:21 »
Where there are grey areas, it would be best to adopt a friendly tone when telling people that they are in the wrong place. The tech support in the FF7Voice board case would be a good reason for a stronger unofficial warning; personally I'd reserve official warnings, even if they don't make any changes to the person's ability to post, for more major offences like pirated edition threads, or for repeated offences. If a person is warned unofficially about posting something in what they definitely know is the wrong board, because they've been warned about exactly the same thing before, an official warning might be in order.

Basically, warnings that show up on a person's profile should be used a little less liberally and be used for cases in which unofficial ones have failed to change the person's behaviour. This would mean that warnings would do a better job of identifying the real trouble causers and would mean that we wouldn't have every other new member with a black (or green) mark by their name.
« Last Edit: 2010-07-23 18:33:09 by Kudistos Megistos »

obesebear

  • Administrator
  • No life
  • *
  • Posts: 3213
  • Karma: 109
    • View Profile
Re: The Rules
« Reply #15 on: 2010-07-23 18:59:33 »
Well, I could be enticed to change my view on things, but your general smartass approach isn't going to do it.   A warning does nothing.  If that person chooses to continue to break the rules, whatever it may be, it becomes likely they are moderated.  How many people are moderated?  2? 3?  How many members do we have normally active around here? 30?   So I would dare say warning seems to be quite effective.

If people feel like disagreeing with a mod will get them in trouble, so what?  I like to think of Qhimm as a pretty good judge of character and would hope he wouldn't appoint people who would be so petty, I know the 3 we currently have aren't.   As a matter of fact, since I've been a member I haven't witnessed anyone being reprimanded or having a grudge held for disagreeing in a civil manner.

You might also like to know that there have been a handful of people who have only been warned via PM.  We're human... sometimes I feel like dishing out high percentage watched warnings, sometimes I feel a PM will suffice.  The fact is, activity on the forums is the same as it has always been, and for the most part things are being kept in check better than usual by the members themselves.  So I'll go ahead and give myself a pat on the back.  Well done, bear, well done.  On and ideal forum I should barely have to do anything, and that's what I'm striving for.

Kudistos Megistos

  • Banned
  • No life
  • *
  • Posts: 3936
  • Karma: 1
    • View Profile
Re: The Rules
« Reply #16 on: 2010-07-23 19:24:46 »
Well, I could be enticed to change my view on things, but your general smartass approach isn't going to do it.

Smartass approach? Explain. I'm not going to sugarcoat my arguments, and if someone says something that I think is fallacious, I'm going to speak up. I don't care if you're a newbie, a normal member or a mod. If Qhimm himself says something that I think is stupid, I'm going to tell him that I think it's stupid.

Oh, and responding to tone doesn't refute the points people are making. I don't like the tone you've used when discussing this either, but I'm doing my best to respond to the actual points being made.

A warning does nothing.

Not when everyone has one.

If people feel like disagreeing with a mod will get them in trouble, so what?

I was responding to an implication that my point was weaker because I was the only person making it. If people are afraid to disagree with a mod, then it means that pointing out that no-one else was disagreeing with the rules isn't a convincing argument.

I like to think of Qhimm as a pretty good judge of character and would hope he wouldn't appoint people who would be so petty

Qhimm also doesn't like having to deal with problems at these forums. I remember reading a thread where he was seriously contemplating appointing anyone who asked for mod power. That was a long time ago, but he might have been in that mindset again.

As a matter of fact, since I've been a member I haven't witnessed anyone being reprimanded or having a grudge held for disagreeing in a civil manner.

Neither have I, but I also haven't seen a mod say anything like

It's preferable because that is how I've chosen to do things.

I'm not sure whether you were being sarcastic or tongue-in-cheek here, but if you're not, it's reason for serious concern. That comes across as saying that you care more about power than making the forums a better place, and if that is how you think, then it isn't such a stretch to assume that you might use your mod powers because of a disagreement. Politicians who think like that certainly don't refrain from using their power to silence opposition.

DLPB

  • No life
  • *
  • Posts: 8855
  • Karma: 254
  • My love is as sharp as a needle in your eye.
    • View Profile
Re: The Rules
« Reply #17 on: 2010-07-23 20:32:42 »
I actually like the new rules.  I think being tough on most things is the right way to go.  I do have some disagreements though about

Double posting.  I don't know why everyone gets in a tiz about infrequent double posting, especially when it is separated by hours.   I have been placed on warning level for a small misdemeanour which would have been better warning me for instead of landing a nice "Watched" status on me which seems too gung ho for what I did.  I think as long as a double post is separated by hours or is a post releasing a new mod version, it should be ok.  On my forum, I deployed a mod that adds posts under a certain time to the one above it.  So it ended all the need for warnings and so forth.


Still, overall, I think a hard line on most things is ok if it keeps a bit of order.  I would also remove all that hermoor stuff and silly topics which attract trouble.  I don't think they are adding to this forum in the slightest, and are probably contributing to trolling.





The Seer of Shadows

  • No life
  • *
  • Posts: 1146
  • Karma: 0
  • I used to be indecisive. But now, I'm not sure...
    • View Profile
Re: The Rules
« Reply #18 on: 2010-07-23 21:22:31 »
It's preferable because that is how I've chosen to do things.

I'm not sure whether you were being sarcastic or tongue-in-cheek here, but if you're not, it's reason for serious concern. That comes across as saying that you care more about power than making the forums a better place, and if that is how you think, then it isn't such a stretch to assume that you might use your mod powers because of a disagreement. Politicians who think like that certainly don't refrain from using their power to silence opposition.

The context of it suggests otherwise, but I'm quite certain that is a joke.

Double-posting should only be allowed if it's necessary in order to bump the topic.  Unfortunately, that produces another "grey area" (like we haven't got enough of those :P).  My say is that if you are ready to release a new version of a mod, or if you have some other major update, then go for it... if your topic is not on the first page of the board.  But other people will be more lenient about it than I am.  I personally twitch a little whenever I see two posts in a row by the same person.  It's probably my OCD.

Kudistos Megistos

  • Banned
  • No life
  • *
  • Posts: 3936
  • Karma: 1
    • View Profile
Re: The Rules
« Reply #19 on: 2010-07-23 21:34:14 »
My say is that if you are ready to release a new version of a mod, or if you have some other major update, then go for it... if your topic is not on the first page of the board.

I'd say that's actually quite a good idea

Marc

  • Insane poster
  • *
  • Posts: 445
  • Karma: 0
  • I hear Voices ... in my head
    • View Profile
Re: The Rules
« Reply #20 on: 2010-07-24 02:46:55 »
IF I may chime in :

- LOVE how Game Tweaking has turned out.  Basically a release forum.  Makes looking at actual meat and potatoes stuff easier which is, with tech related, what this forum is about
- 100% agree on the fact taht it might be confusing for some users until descriptions are fixed
- I was expecting alot of the traffic in game tweaking to get moved to programming feedback but it seems to also have been split to general oddly enough
- I also agree that the warning system seems a bit drastic.  Good idea but perhaps a PM warning should be standard before the first actual warning is given out ?  Or simply that the icon only shows up after the second one but the user is advised by the system to make sure he's aware at the first one ?
- I also agree the comments about Hermoor should be purged.  It's in unrelated and I don't really care for it  which is why I've kept quiet but since this has been brought up I'll speak my mind.

I don't see how Hermoor/Tyr was treated as being fear.  I disliked Hermoor for his posts before all that pron crap because he was an immature prick (ie: viashino's thread) and Tyr's posts were definitely trollish and he should have been warned but the way some users baited him deserved harsh warnings if you ask me. 

Leave the guy alone.  He's got enough problems in his life without the bullies of he internet ganging up on him.  And Ammo wasn't a good example in that case either in my eyes.  Certainly wasn't fitting of his position.

Give the guy a chance next time.  Seifer is a good example of what can happen when you do.

obesebear

  • Administrator
  • No life
  • *
  • Posts: 3213
  • Karma: 109
    • View Profile
Re: The Rules
« Reply #21 on: 2010-07-24 05:51:03 »
So in order to try to steer this sticky thread back on topic...   Exactly what topics that have been moved to General should have been moved to Tech Related?  Examples/links would be nice.   Something might can be worked out if someone can make a good argument for it.  Tech Related is usually pretty barren.

Kudistos Megistos

  • Banned
  • No life
  • *
  • Posts: 3936
  • Karma: 1
    • View Profile
Re: The Rules
« Reply #22 on: 2010-07-24 15:05:43 »
Really, anything that's related to modding the game is better off in tech related than in general. Maybe there might be a case for the very vague threads to not go in tech related, but something like this is better off in a tech forum. I suppose it all comes down to whether Halkun will rape you for filling tech related with noobs, but if not, it would certainly help, especially if people are determined for game tweaking to be releases and WIPs only and Qhimm isn't going to allow the forum structure to be changed.

It would certainly be much easier for newcomers to understand that game tweaking is for releases and tech related is for understanding the mechanics that need to be exploited in order to make those releases.

obesebear

  • Administrator
  • No life
  • *
  • Posts: 3213
  • Karma: 109
    • View Profile
Re: The Rules
« Reply #23 on: 2010-07-24 19:30:18 »
Really, anything that's related to modding the game is better off in tech related than in general. Maybe there might be a case for the very vague threads to not go in tech related, but something like this is better off in a tech forum. I suppose it all comes down to whether Halkun will rape you for filling tech related with noobs, but if not, it would certainly help, especially if people are determined for game tweaking to be releases and WIPs only and Qhimm isn't going to allow the forum structure to be changed.

It would certainly be much easier for newcomers to understand that game tweaking is for releases and tech related is for understanding the mechanics that need to be exploited in order to make those releases.
Agreed.   I'll move that one now and try to go through General at some point next week and move any others...feel free to help.

obesebear

  • Administrator
  • No life
  • *
  • Posts: 3213
  • Karma: 109
    • View Profile
Re: The Rules
« Reply #24 on: 2011-02-28 18:56:47 »
Changed the rules around some.  Got rid of some.  Added some.  It's also now prettier because I added colors and strawberries.   As always, suggestions, comments, complaints?