[facepalms *really* hard]
First of all, not only did you necropost, you admitted to necroposting, and you're probably also aware of the fact that the creator of the thread has since LEFT THE FORUMS.
Second of all, your point was completely irrelevant to the topic at hand. The theory isn't "All good games have smoking in them", it's "All games with smoking in them are good".
Get your boolean logic right.